Understanding Apa

Apa is used to ask questions related to objects, actions, or descriptions. It translates to “what” in English and is essential for inquiring about various aspects of the world around you.

Apa – What
Apa yang kamu lakukan? (What are you doing?)

In the example above, apa is used to ask about an action. It helps inquiring about details or specifics of something unknown.

Apa khabar – How are you? (Literally: What news?)
Apa khabar, Ali? (How are you, Ali?)

Here, apa forms part of a common greeting in Malay, asking about someone’s well-being or “what news” they have.

Understanding Siapa

Siapa is employed to ask questions about people. It translates to “who” in English and is crucial for identifying individuals in various contexts.

Siapa – Who
Siapa nama kamu? (Who is your name?)

In this example, siapa is used to inquire about a person’s name. It helps in identifying or getting to know someone.

Siapakah – Who (emphatic)
Siapakah yang datang semalam? (Who came yesterday?)

Here, siapakah is an emphatic form of siapa, adding emphasis to the question about who came the previous day.

Forming Questions with Apa and Siapa

When constructing questions with apa and siapa, it’s essential to place them at the beginning of the sentence, similar to English. However, Malay sentence structure can be more flexible.

Apa – What
Apa yang terjadi? (What happened?)

Siapa – Who
Siapa guru kamu? (Who is your teacher?)

Notice how both apa and siapa are placed at the start of their respective questions, immediately signaling the type of information being sought.

Usage in Different Contexts

Asking about Objects with Apa

Apa can be used to inquire about various objects or things. Its versatility makes it a fundamental word in everyday conversation.

Apa – What
Apa itu? (What is that?)

Apa warna – What color
Apa warna baju kamu? (What color is your shirt?)

Apa yang terjadi – What happened
Apa yang terjadi di sana? (What happened there?)

Asking about People with Siapa

Siapa is indispensable when asking about people. Whether you’re trying to identify someone or learn more about them, siapa is the go-to word.

Siapa – Who
Siapa yang menelefon tadi? (Who called earlier?)

Siapa nama – Who is the name
Siapa nama pelakon itu? (Who is the actor’s name?)

Siapa yang akan datang – Who will come
Siapa yang akan datang ke pesta? (Who will come to the party?)

Combining Apa and Siapa with Other Words

Both apa and siapa can be combined with other words to form more complex questions, thereby enriching your conversational skills.

Apa yang – What (specific)
Apa yang kamu fikirkan? (What are you thinking about?)

Siapa yang – Who (specific)
Siapa yang menulis surat ini? (Who wrote this letter?)

Apa sebab – What is the reason
Apa sebab kamu datang lewat? (What is the reason you came late?)

Siapa punya – Whose
Siapa punya beg ini? (Whose bag is this?)

Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Understanding the correct usage of apa and siapa can be tricky. Here are some common mistakes and tips to avoid them.

Using Apa Instead of Siapa

A frequent error is using apa when siapa is required. Remember, apa is for objects or actions, while siapa is for people.

Incorrect: Apa nama kamu? (What is your name?)
Correct: Siapa nama kamu? (Who is your name?)

Using Siapa Instead of Apa

Conversely, using siapa when apa is needed is another common mistake. Always use apa for non-human inquiries.

Incorrect: Siapa yang terjadi? (Who happened?)
Correct: Apa yang terjadi? (What happened?)

Misplacing Apa and Siapa in Sentences

While Malay allows for some flexibility in sentence structure, placing apa and siapa incorrectly can lead to confusion.

Incorrect: Yang terjadi apa? (Happened what?)
Correct: Apa yang terjadi? (What happened?)

Incorrect: Guru kamu siapa? (Your teacher who?)
Correct: Siapa guru kamu? (Who is your teacher?)

Conclusion

Mastering the use of apa and siapa is fundamental for anyone learning Malay. These words are indispensable for forming questions and understanding responses in everyday conversation. By remembering their specific uses—apa for objects, actions, and descriptions, and siapa for people—you will be well on your way to becoming proficient in Malay. Practice using these words in different contexts, and soon, asking questions in Malay will become second nature. Happy learning!